GovCon 360Dec 11 · ArlingtonDetails
Back to Blog

DCAA Compliance Software· · Updated · 11 min read

How to Choose DCAA Software for a Small GovCon

Four common approaches to DCAA software for small government contractors, from timekeeping apps to GovCon ERPs: what each covers on the SF-1408, what it costs to adopt, and how to choose by contract type, size and who will run it.

How to Choose DCAA Software for a Small GovCon

This guide is for owners, finance leads and bookkeepers at small government contractors who need to pick software for DCAA. Some are preparing for a first cost-type or T&M contract, some have a pre-award accounting system review coming, and some have outgrown a spreadsheet. The market can look crowded: ERPs, accounting systems built for GovCons, QuickBooks add-ons and timekeeping apps all describe themselves as DCAA compliant. Sorting them by what they actually cover makes the choice much simpler.

The short answer

There is no DCAA-approved software. DCAA evaluates your accounting system as a whole against criteria like those on the SF-1408, the Preaward Survey of Prospective Contractor Accounting System it uses to decide whether a contractor's system is adequate. Any tool, or combination of tools, that covers those criteria can work.

Most of the options small contractors compare follow one of four approaches. Many companies combine tools, for example a timekeeping app with a separate payroll provider, so use these as reference points:

  1. QuickBooks Online on its own, set up for government contracting, with labor distribution and indirect rates done in spreadsheets.
  2. A DCAA timekeeping app, such as Hour Timesheet or QuickBooks Time, built around compliant timesheets that sync with QuickBooks: approved hours flow into your books. Depending on the plan, some add payroll, expenses, job costing reports or labor-distribution reporting; indirect rates are calculated outside the app.
  3. A compliance layer on QuickBooks Online, such as WiseCost, integrated with your books in both directions. It reads your accounts, employees, classes and projects from QuickBooks Online and keeps them in sync, then posts the labor cost of each contract back as a journal entry. It covers timekeeping, labor distribution, indirect rates and costs by contract, and QuickBooks Online stays your accounting system.
  4. A GovCon ERP or accounting system, such as Deltek Costpoint, Unanet GovCon, JAMIS Prime or PROCAS, which replaces your accounting system.

For most small contractors with books in QuickBooks Online, fewer than 50 employees and a first or second cost-type contract, the third approach covers what DCAA tests at the lowest cost of change. An ERP starts to earn its cost with more people, more contracts, Cost Accounting Standards coverage or modules such as integrated billing and procurement.

Choose by what your system is missing, not by the label on the software.

What DCAA software has to cover

Most of what the SF-1408 tests falls into two groups. The ledger side: separating direct from indirect costs, tracking costs by contract, and excluding unallowable costs. QuickBooks Online covers that with a GovCon chart of accounts and classes or projects, as we explain in How to Make QuickBooks Online DCAA-Compliant. The labor side is where small contractors usually have the gap:

When you compare tools, check which of those three each one does for you and which remain manual work each pay period.

The four approaches compared

QuickBooks Online on its ownDCAA timekeeping appCompliance layer on QuickBooks OnlineGovCon ERP or accounting system
ExamplesQuickBooks Online with spreadsheetsHour Timesheet, QuickBooks TimeWiseCostDeltek Costpoint, Unanet GovCon, JAMIS Prime, PROCAS
Your accounting systemStays in QuickBooks OnlineStays in QuickBooks; approved hours sync to itStays in QuickBooks Online; labor cost posts to it as a journal entryReplaced; your books move into the new system
DCAA timekeepingSpreadsheets or paperYesYesYes
Labor distribution posted to the ledgerSpreadsheet each pay periodCalculated outside the app from exported hours; some payroll plans add labor-distribution reportingCalculated each payroll period and posted as a journal entryInside the ERP
Fringe, overhead and G&A rates: what each labor dollar really costs, used to price proposals and bill cost-type contractsSpreadsheetCalculated outside the appCalculated from QuickBooks Online transactionsInside the ERP
Integrated billing, procurement, earned valueNoNoNoAvailable, depending on the product and modules
Time to startImmediate, if the chart of accounts is set upDaysConnects in about a minute; time can be logged the same dayWeeks to months, depending on the product
Usually fitsFirm-fixed-price work with no labor charges to supportTeams that mainly need compliant timesheets and already have a labor cost process that worksUnder 50 employees, books in QuickBooks Online, cost-type or T&M work50+ employees, 20+ active contracts, CAS coverage or ERP modules needed

Timekeeping apps differ from each other, so check each one's scope. Some payroll plans add pieces of the labor side: Hour Timesheet's payroll plan lists labor-distribution reporting to the general ledger, and QuickBooks Online Payroll Premium and Elite let you assign each paycheck to classes or projects. Our comparisons of WiseCost vs Hour Timesheet and WiseCost vs QuickBooks Time go through each one.

Find your fit in three questions

How to choose, step by step

  1. Start with your contract types. Firm-fixed-price work alone rarely asks you to support labor charges, although you still need to know what each contract costs to protect your margin, as we cover in Is Fixed-Price the New Default for GovCon Contracts?. Cost-reimbursable, T&M and labor-hour contracts bring DCAA's timekeeping and labor distribution requirements. See Cost-Reimbursable vs. T&M vs. Firm Fixed Price.
  2. Find the gap in your current system. If your books already work in QuickBooks Online, the gap is usually labor: timekeeping, labor distribution and indirect rates. Replacing the ledger would replace parts that already work.
  3. Decide how much of the labor cost work you want automated. Labor distribution and indirect rates have to be calculated every pay period. Built by hand in spreadsheets, they take hours and leave room for formula errors. Software that calculates them leaves you and your CPA the review instead of the rebuild. Our comparison of labor distribution in a spreadsheet, an add-on or an ERP shows the trade-offs of each.
  4. Check your size and module needs. Compare ERPs once you pass roughly 50 employees and 20 active contracts, once revenue reaches $10 to $20 million, or once you need integrated billing, earned value or procurement.
  5. Check your timeline. If a proposal or a review is weeks away, an ERP implementation that runs in months may not be ready. A compliance layer can be working the same week.

When lightweight tools make more sense

Timekeeping apps and compliance layers keep your accounting system where it is. They tend to fit when:

  • You have fewer than 50 employees and are pursuing your first or second cost-type contract.
  • QuickBooks Online already works for your general accounting.
  • Your bookkeeper or CPA works in QuickBooks Online and you want to keep them.
  • You need a working system soon, for a proposal or a review.
  • You want to prove your process before committing to an ERP.

When an enterprise ERP makes more sense

A GovCon ERP replaces your accounting system and puts accounting, projects, time and billing in one place. It tends to earn its cost when:

  • You have more than 50 employees with 20 or more active contracts across agencies.
  • Revenue reaches $10 to $20 million, usually the point at which a company can afford its own in-house accounting team.
  • Cost Accounting Standards apply to your contracts.
  • You need integrated government billing, earned value, procurement or manufacturing from the same system as your accounting.
  • You have outgrown QuickBooks Online as a ledger, with several entities or complex billing.

If several of these describe your company, the investment is probably justified. For how the two ERPs small contractors hear about most compare, see Deltek Costpoint vs Unanet GovCon for a Small Contractor. For a buyer's table of Unanet and its alternatives, see Unanet GovCon Alternatives for Small Contractors.

Questions to ask any vendor

Ask every vendor the same questions, so the answers are comparable. Here is how WiseCost answers each one.

Ask the vendorHow WiseCost answers
Which SF-1408 criteria does your software cover, and which remain manual work?Timekeeping, labor distribution reconciled to payroll and the books, and indirect cost allocation. The ledger side stays in QuickBooks Online, with your GovCon chart of accounts and classes or projects.
What reaches my books: hours, or labor cost by contract?Labor cost by contract and indirect activity, as one journal entry in QuickBooks Online. An admin reviews it before it posts.
Does it calculate fringe, overhead and G&A, and can I trace each rate to its transactions?Yes. The Indirect Rate report calculates them from your QuickBooks Online data and downloads as an Excel workbook with live formulas and the transactions behind each rate.
How are corrections handled after a timesheet is approved or a period is posted?A rejected or reopened timesheet goes back to the employee to fix and resubmit. A posted period that is reopened gets a reversal entry, and the original stays in the books.
Can I export the audit trail for an auditor, with old and new values?Yes. Every change to time entries, timesheets, labor distribution and compliance settings is recorded with the old and new value, and nobody can edit or delete it. It exports to CSV.
Does my data have to migrate, and how long until my team is using it?No migration. WiseCost connects to the QuickBooks Online company you already have in about a minute, and your team can log time the same day.
Who will run it day to day, and what training do they need?Employees log and submit time; approvers sign off; your bookkeeper or CPA runs labor distribution and keeps working in QuickBooks Online.
What does it cost?$149 per month including 5 users, plus $15 per month for each additional user, on top of your QuickBooks Online subscription. There is a 14-day free trial, with no credit card required.

Compare specific tools

The decision isn't permanent

The most expensive outcome is often no decision at all: a contractor still on spreadsheets while weighing an ERP is not building the records an auditor will ask for. Start with what fits your size today. If that is QuickBooks Online with a compliance layer, your chart of accounts, cost pools and timekeeping practices will already be in place if you move to an ERP later.

FAQ

No. DCAA does not approve or certify software. It evaluates your accounting system as a whole, including your written policies and how you follow them, against criteria like those on the SF-1408. Both an ERP and QuickBooks Online with a compliance layer can support those criteria.

It depends on your gap. If your books work in QuickBooks Online and you have fewer than 50 employees, a compliance layer that covers timekeeping, labor distribution and indirect rates, such as WiseCost, usually fits. If you mainly need compliant timesheets and already have a labor cost process that works, a DCAA timekeeping app may be enough. With 50 or more employees, 20 or more active contracts, CAS coverage or a need for integrated billing, compare GovCon ERPs such as Deltek Costpoint and Unanet GovCon.

A timekeeping app records and approves time and sends hours to your accounting system. A compliance layer also turns approved hours and pay into labor cost by contract each payroll period, posts it to the ledger, calculates fringe, overhead and G&A rates, and keeps an audit trail of every change across that cycle, from the time entry to the journal entry.

If your books are in QuickBooks Online, the main alternative to an ERP is to keep QuickBooks Online and add a compliance layer such as WiseCost. If you want to replace QuickBooks Online, other GovCon systems include Unanet GovCon, JAMIS Prime and PROCAS.

Usually past roughly 50 employees with 20 or more active contracts, or when revenue reaches $10 to $20 million and an in-house accounting team becomes affordable. Cost Accounting Standards coverage or a need for integrated billing, earned value or procurement can also make the move worth it sooner.

The Bottom Line

Choosing DCAA software comes down to the gap in your system. If your books work in QuickBooks Online, the gap is usually the labor side, and a compliance layer covers it without replacing anything that works. If you have the size, the contracts or the module needs that an ERP is built for, compare ERPs and plan for the people who will run them. Either way, the goal is an accounting system that holds up to the SF-1408 and keeps you DCAA ready.


Not sure which gaps you have? Take our free DCAA Readiness Self-Assessment to see your readiness score before you compare vendors, or start a 14-day free trial of WiseCost on the QuickBooks Online you already run.

Sources